Curious Cat Management Improvement Blog: Deming, lean thinking, innovation, customer focus, continual improvement, six sigma.
November 2, 2006
What is Wrong with MBA’s

Two interesting posts from Compound Thinking: What is Management?:

Management is helping others become great.

Well said. As Deming would say management’s responsibility is to work on improving the system (to allow everyone in the system to do great work). This encompasses a wide variety of things. Creating sensible hiring processes. Designing systems that allow people to do great work and take pride in what they do. Providing a system of education and training.

What’s wrong with MBAs?:

MBA graduates generally aren’t the kind of people dedicated to helping other people achieve greatness.

Instead, they want to achieve greatness on their own — which can be a worthy goal. It’s just a terrible goal for a manager. Good managers are relentlessly focused on helping the people they work for perform at their best.

There certainly is something about MBA graduates that they often focus on measuring how important they are and how much they should be paid. I think his statement that managers should be dedicated to helping others achieve greatness. This can run counter to performance appraisals schemes where people have to claim responsibility for successes in order to get more cash. It is hard enough to move toward great systems when you have to have credit for each success fought over so it is known who gets the spoils it is much harder.

Related: Joel’s MBADeming’s 14 obligations of managementposts about respect for peopleSeven Deadly Diseases

4 Responses to “What is Wrong with MBA’s”

  1. Evolving Excellence Says:

    Answering Their Own Question…

    Page 48 of the November 27th edition of Forbes has two short articles that have a definite relationship. I doubt the editor realized it at the time. The first, titled Why Detroit Can’t Compete, details the average vehicle price differences…

  2. Curious Cat Management Improvement Blog » Motivate or Eliminate De-Motivation Says:

    I still see far to many managers thinking in a theory x way – 50 years after McGregor’s The Human Side of Enterprise. If there was not such a systemic failure to apply effective management practices and such a desire to substitute motivation for management I wouldn’t see this as a big deal…

  3. Josh Hohman Says:

    Unfortunately, I tend to agree with your assessment of (most) MBAs (I’m a 2005 grad from the Stanford GSB). Of course, it is hasty to make generalizations based on MBA’s as a whole.

  4. Curious Cat Management Improvement Blog » Harvard’s Masters of the Apocalypse Says:

    “Time after time, and scandal after scandal, it seems that a school that graduates just 900 students a year finds itself in the thick of it. Yet there is remarkably little contrition…”

Leave a Reply


Curious Cat Management Improvement Blog © curiouscat.com 2005-2010

Internal Links

Author

John Hunter

Tags

Bill Hunter blogs Books Career Carnival cars commentary Creativity curiouscat Customer focus Data Deming Economics economy engineering executive pay Google Health care Innovation internet Investing IT Japan John Hunter lean manufacturing Lean thinking Madison management managing people Manufacturing overpaid executives Performance Appraisal Process improvement Psychology Quality tools quote respect for people Six sigma Software Development Statistics Systems thinking tips Toyota Toyota Production System (TPS) webcast
Full tag could

Other

Search Blog

Web Search

Management Improvement web search

Recent Comments

  • Nick McCormick: Agreed John. Slogans can be good or bad. They can be effective if the rank and file come up with...
  • Halvard: I have reservations about the Obama Healthcare Plan. Can it create costly effects to my families well being?...
  • Rob: Absolutely excellent videos. Deming is timeless and his message resonates today.
  • Jamie Flinchbaugh: I am curious to watch it. I believe the executives will probably have some ah-has and some good...
  • Jamie Flinchbaugh: Thanks for including me. I’m glad you choose Fail, Learn, Lead. I think it’s a really...
  • ilskan: @Kyle: I suppose so. Ideally you want a happy medium, though; the other end of the spectrum can be pretty...
  • Anonymous: I recently stayed in a ski lodge in the white mountains Arizona for me and the wife’s anniversary....
  • Jamie Flinchbaugh: I’m sure you are right that there are many frustrated people, but one of the benefits of...
  • Karen Wilhelm: Great find – lean starters in need of do-it-yourself training curriculum can really benefit from...
  • Mark Graban: Nice post, John. I’ll hold out hope that this is more than a form of industrial tourism. Executive...

Archives

November 2006
M T W T F S S
« Oct   Dec »
 12345
6789101112
13141516171819
20212223242526
27282930